Clear and Open

Clear and Open

Human Maturity

When Reasoning Itself Becomes Suspect

The erosion of evidence, intellectual accountability, and the capacity to negotiate reality

Josef Shapiro's avatar
Josef Shapiro
Nov 17, 2026
∙ Paid

How was your Mercury Retrograde? Its three weeks concluded on November 12, but usually has a perceptible shadow before and after, and this time was punctuated on the 13th with the nationwide ground stop, which more or less coincided with a major Microsoft Outlook outage. Hope you weren’t flying that day, and that you had some positive perceptual reorganization during the period without too many things breaking.

Today’s article is about the reclamation of reason as a faculty for negotiating reality, but first…

Announcements:

My awakening group is ongoing bi weekly. If you’re seriously interested in spiritual awakening, hit reply for info or questions.

Last week’s podcast The Persecution of Reason began with a reading of the first few paragraphs of this article and extrapolated from there. I also showed the boundary-crossing and sexual impropriety markers in the natal chart of the recently convicted Russell Brand.

The next introductory Developmental Astrology course is coming soon!

What if your astrological chart could reveal not just who you are, but who you have the potential to become?

Registration is now open for From Personality to Development, my 12-week Developmental Astrology intro course begins January 13, 2027.

Learn to interpret Vedic astrology charts as maps of human development, revealing personality patterns, developmental challenges, and opportunities for growth and transformation.

Register before January 1 and use code EARLYBIRD to save $100 on tuition.


Reasoning is among the most fundamental capacities through which human beings negotiate reality. It allows individuals to distinguish what they believe from what they can justify, evaluate competing interpretations, identify contradictions, and revise conclusions when new evidence becomes available. Without these capacities, disagreement becomes a contest of assertions rather than a means of discovering what is true.

Yet in many contemporary interpersonal and cultural environments, something peculiar appears to be happening. People routinely express conclusions without supporting evidence, treat their interpretations as self-validating, and resist revising their positions when contradictory information is presented. More strikingly, the very practices that make reasoning possible (asking for evidence, examining inconsistencies, and testing the validity of claims) can be regarded as adversarial, excessively intellectual, or relationally inappropriate.

The concern extends beyond the familiar observation that people reason poorly. It raises the possibility that some individuals no longer recognize the difference between reasoning and merely asserting what they believe.

A person may express an opinion, defend it vigorously, reject contrary evidence, and leave the exchange convinced that they have engaged in a reasoned discussion. Yet at no point have they meaningfully examined whether their conclusion follows from the available evidence.

The distinction matters because reasoning is not simply the production of thoughts, arguments, or explanations. It is a disciplined relationship to reality in which conclusions remain accountable to evidence.

When that accountability disappears, reasoning becomes indistinguishable from belief maintenance.

The Difference Between Having an Opinion and Reasoning

Everyone has opinions. Human beings continuously interpret events, evaluate other people, make predictions, and form judgments about their circumstances. Much of this activity occurs automatically, without deliberate examination.

There is nothing inherently problematic about this. Immediate interpretations are necessary for navigating ordinary life. People cannot investigate every assumption before deciding what to eat, whom to trust, or how to respond to a conversation.

Problems arise when an interpretation is treated as an established fact without sufficient justification, particularly when the claim is consequential, contested, or potentially damaging to another person.

Consider someone who says, “You’re manipulative.”

The statement appears straightforward, but it contains several elements that require examination. What behavior occurred? What makes that behavior manipulative rather than mistaken, defensive, confused, or simply unwelcome? What evidence supports the inference about intention? Have alternative explanations been considered?

A person engaged in reasoning can address these questions. They may ultimately conclude that the characterization is justified, but the conclusion follows an examination of the relevant evidence.

A person who merely asserts an opinion may regard the questions themselves as unnecessary.

“I think you’re manipulative.”

“Why?”

“That’s just how I see it.”

The exchange has reached an epistemic dead end. The person’s belief is offered as justification for itself. This is circular reasoning in a particularly simple form: I believe something because I believe it.

The distinction can be obscured by the language of personal perspective. Expressions such as “That’s my truth,” “I’m entitled to my opinion,” or “That’s how I experienced it” may serve legitimate purposes. Individuals have privileged access to aspects of their own subjective experience, and their reports of that experience deserve consideration.

But subjective experience and interpretations of external reality are different kinds of claims.

“I felt dismissed during our conversation” is a report of subjective experience.

“You dismissed me because you don’t respect me” is an interpretation involving another person’s behavior, intention, and character.

The first statement may be accepted as an account of what the speaker experienced. The second requires evidence beyond the speaker’s conviction.

The distinction does not invalidate subjective experience. It clarifies what subjective experience can and cannot establish.

A person can accurately report feeling threatened while incorrectly concluding that another person intended to threaten them. Someone can genuinely feel disrespected while misinterpreting the behavior that produced that feeling. Emotional experience is real, but its explanation remains subject to examination.

When these categories collapse, the intensity or sincerity of an experience can become a substitute for evidence about its cause.

This creates an environment in which interpretations become difficult to question without appearing to question the legitimacy of the person having them.

The Burden of Justification

A basic principle of rational discourse is that the person advancing a claim bears responsibility for providing appropriate justification.

The strength of that justification should be proportionate to the significance of the claim.

Ordinary conversation does not require formal proofs. People routinely make reasonable observations based on incomplete information. But when an assertion is disputed, consequential, or accusatory, the obligation to explain its basis becomes more important.

Calling someone dishonest, abusive, narcissistic, toxic, or controlling is not merely an expression of personal preference. Such characterizations can influence relationships, reputations, decisions, and social standing.

They therefore warrant examination.

What happened? What evidence supports the characterization? How reliably does that evidence distinguish the proposed explanation from plausible alternatives?

Without these questions, labels can function as conclusions that bypass the work necessary to justify them.

This is particularly common when psychological terminology is used as a form of moral or interpersonal judgment. Someone may characterize another person as a narcissist without identifying a coherent pattern of behavior, considering alternative explanations, or distinguishing a clinical concept from ordinary self-centeredness.

The label may carry the appearance of psychological sophistication while functioning primarily as an expression of disapproval.

A related problem occurs when the burden of proof is reversed.

One person makes an unsupported accusation. The accused person requests evidence or presents information contradicting the claim. Rather than addressing that information, the original speaker demands that the accused person prove the accusation false.

This reverses the normal responsibility for justification.

An unsupported claim does not acquire credibility merely because another person cannot conclusively disprove it.

Nor does the presentation of contradictory evidence automatically establish the opposite conclusion. Evidence must be evaluated for relevance, reliability, completeness, and explanatory power.

The governing principle is that claims remain accountable to evidence, regardless of who makes them or how strongly they are held.

When Evidence Becomes an Interpersonal Offense

Perhaps the more troubling development is the tendency, in some environments, to treat the examination of evidence as an inappropriate form of interpersonal behavior.

Consider two people attempting to understand a conflict.

One person describes what happened, identifies specific statements or actions, explains how those events informed their interpretation, and invites the other person to examine the account.

The response is, “This feels like case-making.”

The phrase is revealing.

It describes a subjective reaction, but it also characterizes the act of assembling evidence as potentially adversarial.

There are circumstances in which this concern is legitimate. A person can selectively present facts, overwhelm another with arguments, or conduct a conversation as though prosecuting a case rather than seeking understanding. Reasoning can be used instrumentally to dominate, intimidate, or protect a predetermined conclusion.

But these possibilities do not establish that presenting evidence is inherently adversarial.

When two people disagree about what happened, examining the relevant facts is among the most direct ways to develop a more accurate shared understanding.

If someone believes a conflict arose because a commitment was broken, it is reasonable to examine what was agreed upon, what subsequently occurred, and whether the original interpretation remains justified.

Such examination may be uncomfortable. It may expose mistakes, inconsistencies, or previously unrecognized responsibilities. But discomfort does not establish that the inquiry is inappropriate.

The conversation can become distorted when the emotional response to an argument displaces consideration of the argument itself.

Instead of asking whether the evidence supports the conclusion, attention shifts to whether presenting the evidence feels sufficiently relational, compassionate, or emotionally acceptable.

The shift can create an asymmetry.

An unsupported accusation is treated as an acceptable expression of experience, while the effort to examine its accuracy is characterized as defensive, aggressive, or excessively intellectual.

The person making the accusation is not required to justify it. The person responding to the accusation is criticized for attempting to do so.

This is an inversion of epistemic accountability.

Of course, the emotional conditions of a conversation matter. Timing, tone, mutual respect, and the capacity to remain engaged can influence whether an exchange is productive. A technically sound argument delivered with contempt may undermine the possibility of mutual understanding.

But the emotional conditions of reasoning and the validity of reasoning are distinct questions.

An argument can be logically valid and relationally insensitive. It can also be emotionally comforting and factually mistaken.

Mature dialogue requires attention to both dimensions without allowing either to erase the other.

Logical Fallacies and the Appearance of Reasoning

Logical fallacies are commonly understood as errors in argumentation. Their significance extends beyond technical mistakes because they can allow people to preserve conclusions while avoiding the evidence that would test them.

An ad hominem argument shifts attention from the merits of a claim to some characteristic of the person advancing it. Rather than addressing the evidence, the speaker attacks the other’s intelligence, character, motives, or psychological condition.

The attack may be emotionally satisfying, but it does not establish that the original argument is false.

A straw man argument replaces another person’s actual position with a distorted or simplified version that is easier to reject.

For example, someone argues that emotional experiences should not automatically determine conclusions about external events. Another responds, “So you’re saying feelings don’t matter.”

The response attacks a position that was never advanced.

The original argument concerned the relationship between experience and evidence. The substituted argument concerns whether emotional experience has value.

By changing the proposition under examination, the speaker avoids engaging with the actual claim.

Circular reasoning occurs when the conclusion is assumed in the justification offered for it. A person concludes that someone is untrustworthy, interprets ambiguous behavior as evidence of untrustworthiness, and then uses that interpretation to confirm the original judgment.

The reasoning never leaves the assumptions that generated the conclusion.

Moving the goalposts occurs when the standards required to establish a claim change after the original standards have been satisfied. Evidence is requested, provided, and then dismissed because some additional requirement has suddenly become necessary.

These patterns share an important feature: they allow the speaker to maintain the appearance of argumentation without remaining genuinely accountable to the proposition under examination.

Not every mistaken argument is a deliberate evasion. People can commit fallacies unintentionally, misunderstand one another, or reason from incomplete information.

The developmental significance lies in what happens when the error is identified.

Can the person recognize the discrepancy and revise their position? Or does the recognition of error produce another strategy for preserving the original conclusion?

The answer reveals something more important than familiarity with the vocabulary of logic.

It reveals the person’s relationship to correction.

The Obligation to Update

Reasoning is often described as the ability to construct arguments, but this definition is incomplete.

A person may be exceptionally skilled at producing explanations, identifying weaknesses in opposing positions, and defending conclusions. None of these abilities guarantees that the person is using reasoning to discover what is true.

The decisive question is whether the conclusion remains open to revision.

Suppose someone believes that a colleague deliberately excluded them from a meeting. They confront the colleague, who explains that the invitation list was generated automatically and provides evidence that several other people were omitted through the same error.

The original interpretation may have been understandable. But the new evidence changes what can reasonably be concluded.

The person now has an opportunity to update their understanding.

They might recognize that the exclusion was accidental, acknowledge the misunderstanding, and reconsider the emotional conclusions they drew from it.

Alternatively, they might insist that the omission still demonstrates disrespect, reinterpret the technical error as evidence of hidden intention, or shift attention to unrelated grievances.

The second response protects the original belief by making it increasingly resistant to correction.

This is not necessarily a failure of intelligence. It may reflect motivated reasoning, emotional investment, social identification, or difficulty tolerating uncertainty and error.

The person may possess considerable analytical ability while using that ability to defend rather than examine their assumptions.

Reasoning becomes more reliable when individuals can ask not only, “What supports my conclusion?” but also, “What evidence would lead me to change it?”

This question introduces a condition that self-validating belief lacks: the possibility of being wrong.

If no conceivable evidence could alter a conclusion, the conclusion is no longer functioning as an ordinary empirical judgment.

It has become insulated from examination.

This does not mean every belief must be abandoned whenever contrary evidence appears. Evidence varies in quality, and apparently contradictory information may itself be mistaken or incomplete. Responsible reasoning involves weighing evidence rather than automatically accepting the latest challenge.

But the willingness to reconsider must remain operative.

Without it, arguments become instruments of preservation rather than inquiry.

Subjectivism and the Confusion of Authority

Contemporary culture has increasingly recognized the importance of subjective experience. This recognition has legitimate value.

People have historically been dismissed, silenced, or pressured to subordinate their experiences to institutional, familial, or social authority. Greater attention to individual perspectives can correct these distortions and make previously ignored information available.

The difficulty arises when the legitimacy of subjective experience is extended into an unrestricted authority over claims about external reality.

An individual’s experience deserves consideration because it is part of what occurred. But the individual’s interpretation of that experience is not automatically authoritative over every other relevant fact.

The distinction is essential to interpersonal understanding.

Two people may experience the same event differently. Their emotional responses can both be genuine while their interpretations of the event remain incompatible.

Resolving the disagreement requires more than affirming that each person has a perspective. It requires examining what can be established, what remains uncertain, and which interpretations are best supported.

If every interpretation is treated as equally valid simply because someone holds it, the possibility of shared inquiry diminishes.

Disagreement becomes an encounter between private realities, neither of which is required to answer to evidence beyond itself.

The language of personal truth can intensify this confusion.

There are meaningful truths about subjective experience: what someone felt, feared, hoped, remembered, or valued. But factual claims about events, intentions, and causal relationships cannot be made true solely through personal conviction.

The fact that someone sincerely believes a proposition may explain their behavior. It does not establish the proposition’s accuracy.

This is not an argument for dismissing subjective experience in favor of supposedly objective observers. Human perception and interpretation are always situated, incomplete, and susceptible to error.

Precisely for that reason, reasoning requires methods for testing interpretations against evidence that does not depend entirely on the interpreter’s preferences.

The purpose is not to eliminate perspective but to make perspective corrigible.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Josef Shapiro.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Josef Shapiro · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.